Full Program »
Explanatory Relevance and Contrastive ExplanationThis paper argues that the only role for the context in which an explanation is given is to fix a contrastive fact as the object of explanation. First, I argue that there is no determinate object of explanation until that object has been rendered in the contrastive form of P rather than Q. The main premise of this argument is explanatory pluralism. Second, I show how no other contextually supplied information is needed once a contrast has been set. This claim requires that the explanatory relevance relation be determined by the kind of contrast being explained.
Ohio State University